The debate over the format of the College Football Playoff has been nearly as heated — if not more so — than the order of the teams themselves. And with good reason. After just three seasons with the current 12-team format, the CFP committee announced that it will expand to 24 teams starting in 2027.
The change was expected, but that doesn’t mean we have to accept it. To debate the pros and cons of the new system, we enlisted Student Section’s own Ethan Cadeaux, Mike Garbett and Colin Ward-Henninger. Here are their answers to five burning questions about the 24-team CFP.
1. Was expanding the CFP to 24 teams the right decision?
Ethan: No. The CFP committee just expanded to 12 teams three seasons ago, and that’s not even close to enough of a sample size to determine its success. Expansion seemed inevitable, but we didn’t even give the 12-team format a chance. Now, the 24-team format has the risk of looking like a participation event, at least early on. I think anything greater than 16 teams is a risk.
Editor's Picks
Mike: No. I’d have to agree with Ethan that we’re taking a good thing too far. The 12-team format already provides plenty of opportunities for deserving teams to compete for a national championship, while preserving some of the urgency and importance of the regular season. Four teams wasn’t enough (we’re looking at you, FSU), but 12 seems an appropriate number. At 24 teams, we’re going to be rewarding teams for good-but-not-great seasons and watering down what it means to earn a playoff spot. Part of what makes college football special is that getting there should be difficult. Let’s not lose sight of that.
Colin: Yes. Wow guys, way to leave me out on an island! You both raise excellent points that are the main sources of consternation, but to me the 24-team format can actually heighten the fan experience. We get more playoff games on campus, higher stakes for postseason matchups and a chance for a true Cinderella to win a national championship. As far as rewarding good-but-not-great seasons, I don’t necessarily see a problem with that. Don’t we want the best teams competing for the title, regardless of if they had a couple of off nights? If they’re really undeserving, they’ll get bounced in the opening round anyway.
2. Does a 24-team playoff make the regular season more exciting or less meaningful?
Mike: Less meaningful. The 12-team format strikes a reasonable balance, giving deserving teams a legitimate opportunity to compete for a national championship without diminishing the importance of the regular season. Expanding to 24 teams takes that too far. When four-loss teams can realistically find themselves in the playoff conversation, regular-season games become less meaningful. College football is special because every loss can have major consequences. We shouldn’t lose that sense of urgency just to accommodate more teams (well, let’s be realistic: make more money). Twelve teams provide plenty of access; 24 is far too many.
Colin: More exciting. Here’s the thing: every loss still has major consequences. Making the final 24 isn’t a guarantee for any program, so those regular-season matchups still carry tremendous weight. Plus, in the expanded format with an extra round of games, those eight first-round byes are going to be a hot commodity, adding even more importance to maintain a pristine record and high ranking. The CFP committee also announced new scheduling standards that will incentivize more compelling non-conference matchups during the regular season, which should mean more big-time games from the jump. I just can’t see the fans being any less invested in regular-season matchups because 12 more teams make the playoffs.
Ethan: Less meaningful. I hear you, Colin, but this past Saturday was one of the best regular season weeks in recent memory with seven matchups between CFP-ranked teams. Under a 24-team format, I’d argue most of those games would have had far less playoff urgency, while a matchup like Northwestern-Iowa would have carried more weight for teams on the bubble. Yes, the 24-team format means more schools will remain alive in November, but that doesn’t necessarily mean more excitement, especially when the sport’s powerhouses are pretty much locked into a playoff berth every season. Rivalries and major upsets carry less weight, while Power Four conference championship games are now on their way out.

3. Who are the biggest winners and losers under the new format?
Mike: The biggest winners are college towns. More playoff games on campus (16, a massive jump from four under the current format) mean more opportunities for fans to travel, fill hotels and restaurants, and bring significant revenue into their communities. One potential downside: Many of those games potentially being played after students have finished exams and headed home for winter break. The biggest losers, meanwhile, are conference title games and traditional bowl games, which will become even more marginalized or face extinction.
Colin: Couldn’t agree more with Mike on college towns and fans being the most important winners. Give me as many frenzied playoff games on campus as possible, and more fans will have meaningful games to watch deep into November. Programs that have found themselves on the fringes of the playoff (thinking of BYU, Iowa State, South Carolina, etc.) are also winners, since they’ll have less pressure to be perfect, with a solid season potentially being enough to give them a chance to prove their worth on the national stage. Biggest losers are Power Four conference championships and traditional bowl games, though I’m not sure many were clamoring for more Initech-Intertrode PC Load Letter Bowls.
Ethan: Let’s be honest, the winners of expansion are the Power Four middle-class teams. Any 9-3, or even 8-4, SEC or Big Ten team will likely make it in; gone are the days of the season being over with three-plus losses. ESPN, of course, is a big winner with rights to 12 additional playoff games. The losers are simple: the Group of Six, which still only earns one automatic bid. Traditionalists and college football purists, with Power Four conference title games eliminated. But the biggest loser? The casual college football fan, who will be told expansion means more meaningful football, when that’s simply not the case.
4. With 16 playoff games now being played on campus, is this the biggest win for college football fans?
Colin: Absolutely, and I think this is a good opportunity to take a step back and remember what college football is all about. Rankings and championships create competition, and competition brings out the best in fans. With 16 games on campus, we’re going to see an entirely new level of spirit, excitement and creativity from students, and I, for one, simply can’t wait. Going back to Ethan’s point about casual fans, they’ll be much more interested in tuning in to see a mob of rabid fans in an opening-round CFP game — even if they have no connection to the schools — than a random postseason bowl.
Ethan: Yes, sir. More playoff games on campus is one of the few benefits of expansion. I will never forget the atmosphere in South Bend for Notre Dame-Indiana and in Columbus for Tennessee-Ohio State. There’s something special about big-time games being played on campus instead of at a neutral site. However, that all sounds better in theory. December and January usually overlap with winter break, as Mike mentioned, meaning student sections may be thin. And for the final eight teams that make it in, there’s a chance they’d have to play two true road games in the playoffs. The expanded playoff is a win for the top eight seeds, but less clear for everyone else.
Mike: Make it unanimous. Yes, without a doubt. The atmosphere, traditions and home-field advantage will create an experience that can’t be replicated at a neutral site. Giving students and fans the opportunity to see postseason games in their own stadiums is a tremendous win for the sport. As we’ve seen the past two years, it creates a different level of excitement and energy. Neutral-site games have their place, but there’s something undeniably special about a playoff atmosphere on a college campus. Beginning next season, we’ll have 16 of them. If there’s one thing the expanded playoff got right, it’s this.
5. If you could change one thing about the new playoff format, what would it be?
Ethan: I’d give each Power Four conference winner and the top-ranked Group of Six conference winner a first-round bye. That way, winning your conference still matters a lot — even with Power Four conference championship games a thing of the past. Yes, I know automatic byes became a contentious subject in 2024 when both Boise State and Arizona State earned them, only to lose to much better teams in their first playoff games. But without automatic byes, winning your conference really doesn’t mean much of anything anymore. That makes the college football fan in me quite sad.
Mike: Speaking of sad college football fans, can we please establish clear, consistent and transparent selection criteria? The playoff committee should publish its strength-of-schedule formulas and explain what separates one at-large contender from another. There’s nothing wrong with debate over the final playoff spots; that’s part of the fun, right? But when fans, coaches and media members are left guessing about how the committee weighs wins, losses, schedules and quality victories, the process can lose credibility.
Colin: OK guys, those are very logical and reasonable tweaks, but come on, let’s get nuts! The first round proceeds as normal, but for the Round of 16 — hear me out — we let the top eight seeds pick their opponent. Imagine Kirby Smart confidently striding up to the podium in his Georgia visor during a televised 2027 event, announcing that his No. 1 Bulldogs, who are supposed to be matched up with No. 17 Houston, will instead choose to play No. 9 Florida just to stick it to the Gators. Now that’s drama! Top seeds picking their opponent would eliminate any whining about getting a tough draw, while also allowing teams to target opponents with injury or fatigue concerns to give themselves an easier path. Will it ever happen? Probably not. Would it be peak entertainment? You bet.
More from Student Section: Why college football fans aren’t going anywhere | The ultimate fan guide to CFP rankings.



