Few topics in college football have sparked more discussion than the future of the College Football Playoff. Now, the sport is preparing for another major change.
After three seasons with the current 12-team format, the CFP will double to 24 teams beginning in 2027.
But will a bigger playoff make for a better postseason? Or is college football fixing something that isn’t broken?
Student Section writers Ethan Cadeaux, Mike Garbett and Colin Ward-Henninger weighed in on the decision to expand the playoff field in a group chat.
Editor's Picks
Two aren’t sold on the expansion, while one is ready to embrace it.
Here are their responses:
Ethan: The CFP committee just expanded to 12 teams three seasons ago, and that’s not even close to enough of a sample size to determine its success. Expansion seemed inevitable, but we didn’t even give the 12-team format a chance. Now, the 24-team format has the risk of looking like a participation event, at least early on. I think anything greater than 16 teams is a risk.
Mike: Agree with Ethan that we’re taking a good thing too far. The 12-team format already provides plenty of opportunities for deserving teams to compete for a national championship, while preserving some of the urgency and importance of the regular season. Four teams wasn’t enough (we’re looking at you, FSU), but 12 seems an appropriate number. At 24 teams, we’re going to be rewarding teams for good-but-not-great seasons and watering down what it means to earn a playoff spot. Part of what makes college football special is that getting there should be difficult. Let’s not lose sight of that.
Colin: Wow guys, way to leave me out on an island! You both raise excellent points that are the main sources of consternation, but to me the 24-team format can actually heighten the fan experience. We get more playoff games on campus, higher stakes for postseason matchups and a chance for a true Cinderella to win a national championship. As far as rewarding good-but-not-great seasons, I don’t necessarily see a problem with that. Don’t we want the best teams competing for the title, regardless of if they had a couple of off nights? If they’re really undeserving, they’ll get bounced in the opening round anyway.
Where the debate stands
The split captures the three fault lines running through college football right now.
Ethan’s objection is methodological. The 12-team format is still new. Three seasons is not enough data to call it a success or a failure, and the sport is reshaping itself on instinct rather than evidence. He is not even philosophically opposed to a bigger field. He draws his line at 16.
Mike’s concern is the regular season. If a four-loss team can wander into the playoff conversation, then September and October games lose some of the weight that makes college football different from other sports. The urgency is the product. Dilute the field, dilute the stakes.
Colin is not arguing against either of those points so much as reweighting them. He is betting that the fan experience — more playoff games on campus, more teams still alive deep into the season — outweighs the cost to the regular season. And he is not bothered by lower-seeded teams sneaking in. If they do not belong, he figures, the bracket will sort them out quickly.
Regardless, the committee has already made its call. The field will be 24 in 2027.
Every campus. Every tradition. Every fan. Sign up for the Student Section Newsletter
Mike Garbett is a content specialist working with McClatchy’s Content Innovation Lab.
This report was produced with the assistance of a proprietary tool powered by artificial intelligence and using our own originally reported, written and published content. It was reviewed and edited by our journalists.



