Is Mississippi State QB Kamario Taylor worth $7.5 million? Our writers weigh in

Mississippi State sophomore quarterback Kamario Taylor led the Bulldogs to a 4-0 start before suffering a season-ending toe injury. USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Mississippi State sophomore quarterback Kamario Taylor has reportedly agreed to return to Starkville next season, with On3 reporting the deal is worth $7.5 million and incentives that could push it as high as $9 million. 

Taylor led the Bulldogs to a 4-0 start this season, with Mississippi State ranked as high as No. 16 in the Associated Press Top 25 poll, before having season-ending turf toe surgery in late October. 

Given his relative lack of experience — eight career starts — and the large sum now attached to his name, the question is whether any college quarterback is worth that kind of money, or have we officially lost our minds?

Student Section’s Mike Garbett, Ethan Cadeaux and Colin Ward-Henninger tackled that question while examining all the issues surrounding Taylor’s reported deal.

Editor's Picks

  1. TCU Is About to Host Its Highest-Ranked Opponent in 56 Years. Is Fort Worth Ready?Game Day
  2. The Group Chat: Is it better to have courtside donors? Or courtside students?Fan Culture
  3. Cal-Stanford: The Big Game, the Axe and the wildest finish in historyRivalries

Here are their responses:

Mike: Yes, he’s worth it. And yes, we’ve lost our minds. First, kudos to Taylor for securing the reported $7.5 million. You’re worth whatever someone is willing to pay you, and if a program believes that kind of investment is warranted, good for him. That said, we’re talking about a quarterback with eight career starts who isn’t eligible for the NFL Draft. At some point, we have to ask whether college football has lost perspective. The money being thrown around is staggering, and while players deserve to benefit from their value, the current marketplace is becoming increasingly difficult to justify.

Ethan: Before his injury, there was no player in college football more exciting than Kamario Taylor this season. He made Mississippi State football must-watch TV, something that hasn’t happened since Dak Prescott left campus a decade ago. So, is he worth $7.5M? Yeah, of course he is. The going rate for star players seems to increase every year in the current wild west we call the name, image and likeness (NIL) era. I’m willing to bet that Taylor would have gotten that figure elsewhere, if not more, if he hit the portal. And I’m not sure if Mississippi State would ever recover if they lost Taylor, who grew up a diehard fan.

Colin: This isn’t just about Taylor’s value as a college football player. This is about his value to Mississippi State. If the powers that be have determined that Taylor, a Mississippi native, will elevate Mississippi State to a true contender and become a face of the program who creates a whole new generation of Bulldog fans (eventually drawing the highest-level recruits), then it’s worth it to risk the $7.5 million to retain him. It’s surely a gamble given Taylor’s lack of proven on-field success, but that’s where we are right now. Mississippi State would rather put its chips on the table and risk going bust than watch Taylor potentially lead another program to the natty.

Three writers, three different framings — one sees a marketplace that’s lost perspective, one sees a bargain Mississippi State couldn’t afford to miss, and one sees a brand-building gamble.

All three can be true at once.

Your turn

Have your say and cast your vote below.

Fan vote

Is a college quarterback worth $7.5 million, or have we lost our minds?

Unofficial reader vote. One vote per browser.

Every campus. Every tradition. Every fan. Sign up for the Student Section Newsletter

Mike Garbett is a content specialist working with McClatchy’s Content Innovation Lab.

This report was produced with the assistance of a proprietary tool powered by artificial intelligence and using our own originally reported, written and published content. It was reviewed and edited by our journalists.

Share
Scroll to Top