The Weekend Report Card: College Football Week 11 graded from the stands

A report card listing six schools with blank grade boxes lies over Utah's field goal attempt against Arizona at night
The Weekend Report Card grades Week 11 from the stands. Utah kicker Dillon Curtis attempts a field goal against Arizona. Aryanna Frank / Imagn Images via Reuters Connect

The best part about college sports fandom is that it isn’t limited to the stadium or field. The most memorable fan moments can take place before or after a game, and can involve everything from a clever sign to an enraged mascot. Week 11 in college football checked all those boxes, and we’re here to give you the best โ€” and worst โ€” of what went down.

Here is this week’s college football report card, graded from the stands.

Boise State’s two $1 million kicks: A+

Two kicks. $2 million. One glorious mustache.

With College GameDay visiting Boise State’s campus, there was a unique twist to the classic competition that allows one fan to kick a 33-yard field goal for a chance at $1 million. Before Easton Hanson got his opportunity (oh, there will be more on him later), Boise State legend and retired Dallas Cowboys linebacker Leighton Vander Esch was brought out to kick the same 33-yarder, with $1 million for the Make-A-Wish Foundation on the line.

Editor's Picks

  1. TCU Is About to Host Its Highest-Ranked Opponent in 56 Years. Is Fort Worth Ready?Game Day
  2. The Group Chat: Is it better to have courtside donors? Or courtside students?Fan Culture
  3. Cal-Stanford: The Big Game, the Axe and the wildest finish in historyRivalries

After a disastrous first attempt, Vander Esch โ€” who said he hadn’t kicked since high school โ€” was given a mulligan and made the most of it.

Then it was Hanson’s turn. Not to be outdone, the Boise State freshman strolled up with a Tom Selleck mustache, looking confident as all get out. The dude even brought his own cleats. Legend.

After an epic pep talk from Chuck Pagano, Hanson didn’t throw away his shot.

The pregame payouts were an incredible way for the Broncos to celebrate their first College GameDay appearance since 2010, and they backed it up on the field with a 46-41 win over Oregon State.

Michigan fans shout insults at Whittingham: F

It’s one thing to show your frustration by booing your coach or players on the field, but Michigan fans crossed a line on Saturday when they gathered near the postgame press conference to heckle and shout expletives at head coach Kyle Whittingham after a 31-7 loss at Oregon dropped the Wolverines to 5-5 on the season.

“Go back to Utah,” “Go home,” and “Fire Whitt!” were among the tamer insults, according to the Detroit Free Press. WARNING: Some reasonably audible profanity in the video below.

Look, passionate fans are going to behave passionately, but when you stalk your head coach and shout the way these folks were shouting, it starts to border on harassment. Let’s keep it in the stands.

Arkansas can’t wait three minutes: Detention

Another week, another field-storming fine. But this one could have been avoided with just a bit of patience. As Arkansas fans entered the final minutes of their stunning 34-6 upset of No. 17 South Carolina โ€” snapping the Razorbacks’ dubious stretch of 10 consecutive home SEC losses โ€” they were itching to seize their moment.

Knowing what was ahead, the scoreboard displayed a message saying “3 Minutes To Be Humble,” and the public address announcer repeatedly told fans they would be permitted on the field after waiting three minutes for the field to clear.

Narrator: They did not wait three minutes for the field to clear.

Arkansas was subsequently fined $500,000, which will be paid to South Carolina per SEC policy. This gets detention because they technically broke the rules, but come on โ€” are we really expecting amped-up college fans to patiently sit in the stands for three minutes after a huge win? Seems a bit ridiculous.

Reader vote: Should fans have to wait three minutes to storm the field? Cast yours on Student Section.

Reader vote

Should fans have to wait three minutes to storm the field?

Unofficial reader vote. One vote per browser.

Honor Roll

Wildcats’ 19-hour day: A

Being a college football fan is a full-time job, and the Arizona faithful logged some overtime hours in Saturday’s thrilling 40-39 loss to undefeated No. 2 Utah. With Big Noon Kickoff on campus, Wildcat fans lined up as early as 5 a.m. for Rob Gronkowski’s pregame party before what was originally scheduled as a 5:30 p.m. start. After Utah’s flight was delayed due to the FAA ground stop, however, kickoff was delayed until 8:36 p.m. and the game didn’t end until 12:19 a.m. Sunday.

That means fans who showed up at 5 a.m. experienced a 19-hour game day. Talk about loyalty.

Indiana fan outkicks USC: A-

Fans are often guilty of criticizing players for failing at things the fans themselves could never do. So when a fan actually does something better than a player, it’s worth rubbing it in. In No. 9 Indiana’s 27-13 win over No. 18 USC on Saturday, Trojan kicker Caden Chittenden missed a crucial 27-yard field goal that would have cut the deficit to four points early in the fourth quarter.

As if that didn’t sting enough, during an ensuing timeout an Indiana fan took the field for a promotion and split the uprights on a 35-yarder.

Unforgettable moment for Indiana fans, and a tough beat for Chittenden.

Tiger defends his turf: B+

If you’re going to mess with LSU fans, be ready to answer to Mike the Tiger. Texas players immediately ran over to taunt the LSU student section following Saturday’s 22-21 win in Baton Rouge, and it led to another entry for our list of player-mascot altercations.

LSU players showed restraint by not retaliating, but the same couldn’t be said for Mike the Tiger, who had to be held back from getting in the face of Texas freshman receiver Chris Stewart.

We’re certainly not advocating violence, and fortunately nothing rose to that level, but you have to appreciate it when a mascot defends his turf.

The Weekend Report CardWeek 11
Boise Stateโ€™s two $1 million kicksA+
Michigan fans shout insults at WhittinghamF
Arkansas canโ€™t wait three minutesDetention
Honor Roll
Wildcatsโ€™ 19-hour dayA
Indiana fan outkicks USCA-
Tiger defends his turfB+
Graded from the stands.

Sign of the week

Talk about a stinky situation (I’m sorry). Boise State has yet to win an FBS national championship โ€” shout out to the 1980 Division I-AA champs โ€” and there’s at least one fan who desperately needs that to change.

We’ll forgive the misplaced apostrophe because this person clearly has more pressing concerns. With Saturday’s win, the Broncos clinched a spot in the Pac-12 championship game on Dec. 4, and winning that would give them a strong case to earn an automatic bid to the College Football Playoff. For the sake of this fan, their roommates and their classmates, let’s hope Boise State wins the whole thing.

Share
Scroll to Top