Anyone who has a ticket stub from an unforgettable game tucked away in a special place can understand the appeal of a great piece of memorabilia. From cards to jerseys to championship rings, there are plenty of options out there for fans who want to own a slice of history … if you’re willing to pay for it.
Some of these once-in-a-lifetime artifacts can get up to over a million dollars, with auction houses selling them off to the highest bidder. It may seem crazy, but value is only determined by what someone is willing to pay.
With that in mind, here is a look at six pieces of college sports memorabilia that are worth a small fortune.
Michael Jordan UNC jersey – $1,380,000
MJ is the GOAT, both on the court and at the auction house. Sold by Heritage Auctions in May 2021, Jordan’s North Carolina jersey from his first National Player of the Year season went for a staggering figure.
Editor's Picks
Lew Alcindor UCLA jersey – $1,254,918.84
Well, that dollar amount is oddly specific. Now you see what it takes to score a game-used Alcindor jersey (now Kareem Abdul-Jabbar), photo-matched to the 1968 NCAA Championship net-cutting celebration and 1969 Final Four. Sold by Grey Flannel Auctions in August 2026.
Tom Brady Michigan jersey – $792,000
Nostalgia sells, and this jersey from Tom Brady’s final college game, the 2000 Orange Bowl, fetched some serious cash. Sold by Sotheby’s in December 2024.
Heisman Trophies – up to $504,000

Heisman Trophies are an exceptionally popular auction item, and more than a few college football superstars have seen their trophies sold for extraordinary amounts. Here’s a quick list of some of the top sellers:
- Ricky Williams – $504,000
- Tim Brown – $435,763
- Rashaan Salaam – $399,608
- Bruce Smith – $395,240
- Paul Hornung – $378,000
John Wooden game-worn Purdue jersey – $264,000
The Wizard of Westwood is known as a legendary coach, but Wooden was also three-time All-American guard at Purdue from 1929-32. Sold by Heritage Auctions in 2018.
Pete Maravich game-worn LSU jersey – $176,900
Maravich rewrote the college basketball record books with his scoring prowess, and someone paid a pretty penny to acquire a small piece of his legendary career — a game-worn 1967-68 jersey. Sold by Heritage Auctions in 2025.
Lew Alcindor UCLA championship ring – $156,000

There goes that man again. This ring actually commemorates three consecutive titles from 1967-69, making it even more valuable for someone’s collection. Sold by Heritage Auctions in 2020.
What do you think would be your team’s ultimate piece of memorabilia? Enter your school below to see what would be your Holy Grail.
Your School. Your Holy Grail.
Pick your school and we’ll pull the one keepsake every fan would want: an imagined collectible tied to a real moment, tradition or legend.
Collectibles imaginary, history real. Every keepsake here is hypothetical: none is for sale, and none is claimed to exist, to have been used in a game or to be signed or authenticated. The moments, traditions and people behind them were checked against official athletics, NCAA and news sources.
Colin Ward-Henninger is a content specialist working with McClatchy’s Content Innovation Lab.



