Should college football fans care that the week before rivalry week is a bad slate?

Georgia coach Kirby Smart speak with South Carolina coach Shane Beamer before the start of a NCAA college football game against South Carolina in Athens, Ga., on Saturday, Sept. 16, 2023. Mandatory credit: USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
Georgia coach Kirby Smart speak with South Carolina coach Shane Beamer before the start of a NCAA college football game against South Carolina in Athens, Ga., on Saturday, Sept. 16, 2023. Mandatory credit: USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

It’s hard to believe, but there are only two weeks left in the college football regular season.

But for many fans of the sport, there’s only one week left worth paying close attention to.

Let’s not beat around the bush: this Week 11 college football slate is weak. There’s only one game that features two ranked teams, per the College Football Playoff Rankings – No. 1 Georgia at No. 21 South Carolina – with many schools playing inferior opponents this weekend with rivalry week just around the corner.

College Gameday is headed to Miami, where the Hurricanes are 20.5-point favorites over a Virginia Tech team that just lost to Stanford. And honestly, there weren’t many better locations Gameday could have chosen, unless they wanted to repeat a school from earlier this year.

Editor's Picks

  1. TCU Is About to Host Its Highest-Ranked Opponent in 56 Years. Is Fort Worth Ready?Game Day
  2. The Group Chat: Is it better to have courtside donors? Or courtside students?Fan Culture
  3. Cal-Stanford: The Big Game, the Axe and the wildest finish in historyRivalries

So, should college football fans care that one of the final two weeks of the season doesn’t feature any marquee matchups?

Here are reasons for both for and against it, with a verdict at the end…

Why fans should care

Conference title game berths are on the line this weekend: both Georgia and Miami can clinch a spot in the SEC Championship Game and ACC title game, respectively, with a victory this weekend. If either team loses, that could change the stakes for their rivalry games next weekend.

Speaking of rivalry games, the stakes of many of them depend on results this weekend. USC and UCLA both winning would make next week’s game one of the biggest between the two in recent memory. 

The week before rivalry week can also lead to potential letdowns for top teams that are potentially looking ahead. No. 14 Ohio State has a tough test on the road at Nebraska ahead of next week’s game versus Michigan – which will always be one of the sport’s biggest games of the season despite both programs having down years. The Buckeyes must win out to keep their College Football Playoff hopes alive.

Other teams that face potential letdown spots include No. 15 Iowa (at Illinois), No. 8 Indiana (at Washington), No. 12 Texas Tech (at Baylor), No. 16 Kentucky (at Missouri) and No. 2 Utah (at TCU). 

If I had to guess, at least one of those teams gets upset this weekend. Players are looking ahead, the weather turns in November, and opponents are playing for bowl eligibility. That doesn’t predict an upset, but it’s why upsets happen.

Why fans shouldn’t care

The marquee slate is thin, which will be hard to draw in the eyeballs of casual college football fans. Georgia-South Carolina is the only ranked matchup – South Carolina is ranked by the playoff committee, but not the AP – and the Bulldogs are still favored by over two touchdowns. Even the lone ranked-on-ranked game doesn’t figure to be close.

Several top teams have games this week that should end up in blowouts. No. 3 Alabama hosts Chattanooga, No. 11 Wake Forest faces 3-7 Georgia Tech and No. 7 Miami, as mentioned earlier, is a three-touchdown favorite over Virginia Tech.

Upsets don’t always happen, either. In last season’s penultimate week, no team in the top 14 of the College Football Playoff rankings lost. Of the 16 ranked teams that won, 15 of them won by double digits. There’s a good chance history repeats itself this weekend, too.

Rivalry week is around the corner. It’s natural if casual fans want to save their attention and travel money for next week’s slate.

Games that should still be good

LSU at No. 9 Tennessee: Lane Kiffin’s LSU team is a lot better than its 6-4 record, with two of those losses coming on the final play of the game. The Tigers should give the Volunteers a real test as Tennessee hopes to inch closer to a College Football Playoff berth.

No. 4 UCLA at Michigan: The Bruins remain undefeated in year 1 under Bob Chesney, but a road test at the Big House is a difficult task no matter how bad Michigan is this season. UCLA has repeatedly won low-scoring games; Saturday’s clash could certainly be another nailbiter.

No. 1 Georgia at No. 21 South Carolina: The only ranked matchup deserves a spot on this list, even if the Bulldogs are 16.5-point favorites. The key thing to watch in this one is the health of LaNorris Sellers; South Carolina’s star QB missed last week’s game against Arkansas due to an ankle injury. If he plays, this game could end up being close at the end.

No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri: This would have been a ranked matchup had Missouri kept last week’s game against Georgia remotely close. The Tigers are a good team that have had some bad breaks this season. This matchup is crucial for Kentucky, who must win to keep their College Football Playoff hopes alive after dropping back to back SEC games to Tennessee and Florida.

No. 2 Utah at TCU: A prime letdown spot for the Utes after a thrilling victory over Arizona last week. TCU is a solid team that has the chance to spoil Utah’s chance at a bye. The betting line expects this to be a close game; Utah is currently just a 6.5-point favorite.

The Verdict: Should fans care?

Yes, but care differently. Week 12 isn’t built for spectacle: the committee’s rankings offer only Georgia at South Carolina as a ranked matchup. 

Judge it by stakes and the weekend matters. Georgia can lock up an SEC title-game berth, Miami can do the same in the ACC, and Tennessee and Notre Dame move within reach of the playoff. Undefeated UCLA and Utah walk into road games against opponents with nothing to lose. 

Rivalry Week only means something if these contenders survive. Skip the hype, keep the remote close: this is the week that decides next week. 

Share
Scroll to Top