One of the best rivalries in all of Division III football returned this past Saturday when 31,118 fans packed Yankee Stadium for the 67th Cortaca Jug game between SUNY Cortland and Ithaca College.
Yes, you read that correctly. Over 30,000 people showed up to Yankee Stadium on a Saturday in November to watch Division III football.
You’d think the only way 30,000-plus fans would show up to Yankee Stadium on a Saturday in November is if the Bronx Bombers were playing in the World Series. Nope. That’s the power of college sports.
Here’s what happened in the 67th annual clash of the Cortaca Jug and why it’s important…
Editor's Picks
What happened?
Cortland, ranked No. 9 overall nationally entering the weekend, knocked off Ithaca College 30-23 to cap off an undefeated regular season.
The Red Dragons were led by quarterback Mike Rescigno, who threw for 217 yards and two touchdowns and added another 144 yards and two scores with his legs. Ithaca quarterback Michael Reed turned in a solid performance in his own right, throwing for 283 yards and three touchdowns, but it ultimately wasn’t enough to pull off the upset.
Rescigno’s stellar outing against Ithaca was another high mark on his resume in his campaign for the Gagliardi Trophy, given to the most outstanding Division III college football player of the year — essentially the DIII Heisman Trophy.
Cortland’s undefeated season earned the Red Dragons an Empire 8 title and an automatic berth into the 40-team single-elimination Division III playoffs. Cortland will have a first-round bye before playing its first postseason game (opponent TBD) on Nov. 28.
History of the Cortaca Jug
The annual clash between Cortland and Ithaca is one of the most prominent rivalries in all of Division III college football.
The first meeting between the two schools came nearly a century ago when Cortland defeated Ithaca 12-0 in 1930. Cortland and Ithaca have squared off 83 times since, with Ithaca holding the all-time series record, 44-37-3.
The actual Cortaca Jug was first introduced into the rivalry in 1959 when Cortland captain Tom Decker and Ithaca captain Dick Carmean jointly came up with the idea to award a “traveling trophy.” Decker bought the original ceramic milk jug for $2 from a yard sale. He and Carmean then painted the jug in both schools’ colors: Ithaca’s blue and gold and Cortland’s red and white.
The initial jug lasted until 1985 when a second jug was created once the original one ran out of room to paint scores on it. A third jug made its debut for the 2016 game.
Ithaca has won 39 of the 67 games since the jug became the official trophy of this upstate New York rivalry.
Why the Cortaca Jug is a big deal
Like many great rivalries in college sports, the Cortaca Jug game is built on the schools’ proximity to one another. Ithaca College and SUNY Cortland are separated by just 21 miles. This rivalry dates back almost 100 years, with the “traveling trophy” nearly 70 years old.
Interest in the rivalry spans a lot further than just the local upstate New York community or the two schools’ alumni. Pro-sized crowds are normal for this game; this past weekend’s crowd of 31,118 fans is the fourth-largest in Division III football history (Ithaca-Cortland is responsible for three of the four most-attended DIII games).
The record attendance came in 2019 when 45,161 fans showed up to MetLife Stadium to witness Ithaca take down Cortland 32-20. Just four years ago, 40,232 fans attended the rivalry game at Yankee Stadium in 2022.
Reader vote: Where should the Cortaca Jug be played? Cast yours on Student Section.
Cortaca Jug · Reader vote
Where should the Cortaca Jug be played?
31,118 came to Yankee Stadium. Pick the Jug game’s home.
You picked . Post it on X
Unofficial reader vote. One vote per browser. Percentages only.



